Talent Is Not Amnesty
I watched a lot of people I usually agree with lose their minds this week over a visa program, and I want to slow it down for a minute.
The President sat down with Laura Ingraham and said the country needs H-1B visas because there are certain talents we have to bring in. That was the sentence. The reaction from parts of our own side was immediate and total, as though he had thrown open the southern border and handed out citizenship at the gate.
He did not. And the difference matters more than the anger does.
An H-1B is a temporary work visa attached to a named employer, a named job, and a wage floor. It expires. It can be revoked. The person holding it is tracked, taxed, and tied to the company that sponsored him.
You can argue the program gets abused. You can argue companies use it to undercut American wages, and in plenty of cases I think that argument is flatly correct. But abuse of a legal program and amnesty for illegal entry are two different fights, and we lose the second one every time we pretend they are the same.
Here is why that matters practically. For as long as I have been paying attention, conservatives have made one argument about immigration that has never lost on the merits. There is a line, the line means something, and coming in legally is different from coming in illegally. That argument is the whole ballgame.
The moment we say a vetted, sponsored, temporary work visa is the same thing as walking across a river at night, we have handed back the only ground we were winning on. The other side has spent a long time trying to blur that line. We should not do the job for them.
And look at the record instead of the interview. The Supreme Court just cleared this administration to deport people to third countries, 6 to 3. The removal machinery is running harder than anything in modern memory.
This is not a man who went soft on the border. This is a man who drew a distinction between a chemist on a sponsored visa and a cartel courier, and got treated like he surrendered.
I am not telling you to like the program. I do not, entirely. Raise the wage floors. Audit the companies gaming it.
Cap it where it displaces Americans who can do the work. Fight that fight on its own terms and I will stand next to you the whole way.
But do not burn the man down over a sentence that was true. This country does need some people it does not currently have. Saying so out loud is not betrayal. It is arithmetic.
What did this one do for you?

Join the Conversation